In recent years, a quiet but noticeable trend has emerged: a number of Protestants—often younger men raised in evangelical churches—are converting to Roman Catholicism.
Many cite the rich traditions, sense of transcendence, and visual grandeur of Roman Catholic worship as a draw. The incense, liturgy, ornate cathedrals, and Gregorian chants stand in contrast to the often minimalistic, modern evangelical setting. But from the standpoint of Reformed and Particular Baptist theology, this shift raises deep concerns.
A well-known Reformed Bible teacher once said that Roman Catholicism appeals to the unconverted mind because it traffics in sensuality—aesthetic forms and rituals that stir the flesh but bypass the heart. This essay explores that idea in depth. Are these external forms merely cultural differences, or do they mask deeper theological errors? What is the real danger in this trend, and how should thoughtful Christians respond?
We will examine this phenomenon in five major parts:
- The Aesthetic Appeal of Roman Catholic Worship
- Historical Roots of Roman Catholic Ceremonialism
- Evangelical Critiques: The Five Solas and True Worship
- Flesh vs. Spirit: Why Sensual Religion Cannot Save
- A Call to Treasure the Doctrines of Grace
Definitions of Key Terms
Before proceeding, let us define several key terms for clarity:
- Sacerdotalism: The belief that ordained priests serve as necessary mediators between God and man.
- Sacramentalism: The belief that sacraments (e.g., baptism, Eucharist) confer grace merely by being performed.
- Sola Scriptura: The doctrine that Scripture alone is the final authority for faith and practice.
- Sola Fide: The doctrine that justification comes by faith alone, not by works or ceremonies.
- Unregenerate: Spiritually dead or not born again (see John 3:3; Ephesians 2:1).
- High Church vs. Low Church: Liturgical worship (high church) versus simple, Scripture-focused services (low church).
The Aesthetic Appeal of Roman Catholic Worship
Roman Catholicism engages the senses in worship in ways that few evangelical churches do:
- Smells: Incense is used in Mass to “sanctify” the worship space, an aroma meant to suggest holiness.
- Bells: Liturgical bells are rung during the consecration of the Eucharist, signaling a sacred moment.
- Sights: Cathedral architecture, gold chalices, stained glass, and crucifixes fill the eyes with grandeur.
- Sounds: Gregorian chants, Latin prayers, and pipe organs evoke reverence and mystery.
- Touch and Ritual: The use of rosaries, holy water, genuflection, and candles forms habitual reverence.
To the unconverted heart—especially one weary of the banality of modern life—this can seem deeply spiritual. It appears ancient, rooted, transcendent. But these things bypass the Word of God and appeal to the senses rather than the soul.
As Pastor Jeff Johnson of Grace Bible Church in Conway, Arkansas, warns in his book The Failure of Natural Theology, this type of worship often reflects an attempt to grasp God through man’s sensory experience or philosophy rather than through biblical revelation. It is an aesthetic piety, not a saving one.
Historical Roots of Roman Catholic Ceremonialism
The “smells and bells” didn’t appear out of nowhere. Their origins lie in both Old Testament temple worship and pagan ritualism, merged during the early centuries of the post-apostolic Church.
- 4th–5th Century: As Christianity gained political favor under Constantine, bishops adopted imperial and pagan forms of worship to appeal to Roman culture.
- Medieval Scholasticism: By the 13th century, Thomas Aquinas had developed a full system in which grace flowed through sacraments like physical pipelines.
- Tridentine Catholicism: The Council of Trent (1545–1563) codified ritual, vestments, incense, Latin Mass, and more in reaction to the Protestant Reformation.
- Modern Roman Catholicism: While Vatican II loosened some liturgical rules, the appeal to the senses remains central in Catholic spirituality.
Each of these developments elevated human tradition over Scripture (Mark 7:13) and shifted focus from the gospel to ceremony.
Evangelical Critiques: The Five Solas and True Worship
The Reformation was not merely a protest against corruption. It was a call to recover the gospel of grace buried under centuries of sensual religion and human works.
a. Sola Scriptura vs. Sacred Tradition
The Roman Catholic Church places equal weight on Scripture and “Sacred Tradition.” In contrast, Reformed Baptists and conservative Presbyterians hold that the Bible alone is our infallible rule for faith and practice (2 Timothy 3:16–17).
b. Sola Fide vs. Infused Righteousness
Catholicism teaches that grace is infused through sacraments, and salvation is maintained by cooperation with grace. This undermines the biblical doctrine that we are justified by faith alone (Romans 5:1) in Christ’s finished work, not by ritual or penance.
c. Solus Christus vs. Priestly Mediation
Where the New Testament teaches that Christ is our sole mediator (1 Timothy 2:5), Roman Catholicism insists on a human priesthood to stand between God and man—a denial of the sufficiency of Christ’s priesthood (Hebrews 10:12–14).
d. Soli Deo Gloria vs. Veneration of Mary and Saints
The Catholic system encourages veneration (not technically worship) of Mary and the saints. But Scripture teaches that all glory belongs to God alone (Isaiah 42:8).
e. Sola Gratia vs. Sacramental Grace
Evangelicals affirm that salvation is by grace alone, not by rituals (Ephesians 2:8–9). Catholicism teaches that sacraments dispense grace mechanically—ex opere operato—even if the recipient lacks saving faith.
Flesh vs. Spirit: Why Sensual Religion Cannot Save
Paul warns in Colossians 2:20–23 that man-made religion has “an appearance of wisdom in promoting self-made religion and asceticism… but they are of no value in stopping the indulgence of the flesh” (ESV).
The unregenerate mind often prefers the form of godliness without its power (2 Timothy 3:5). The grandeur of Roman ritual may provide emotional satisfaction, but it cannot produce regeneration. As Jesus told Nicodemus, “You must be born again” (John 3:3).
Why are younger men drawn to it?
- Masculine structure: The hierarchical authority and clarity appeal to men disillusioned with feminized, seeker-sensitive evangelicalism.
- Aesthetic transcendence: The rituals feel weighty and historical.
- Certainty and order: The rules and sacramental system give a sense of control in a chaotic world.
But none of this regenerates. None of this justifies. Only faith in the gospel saves.
A Call to Treasure the Doctrines of Grace
Instead of being lured by ceremonial spectacle, we call you to be enthralled by the truth.
- Study God’s sovereignty in salvation.
- Meditate on the doctrine of union with Christ.
- Understand the imputation of righteousness.
- Rejoice in the sufficiency of Scripture.
- Be nourished by the ordinary means of grace—the Word, prayer, fasting, meditation, fellowship, and baptism/Lord’s Supper properly understood.
The Church does not need Rome’s incense and relics. It needs faithful preaching, reverent worship, and doctrinal clarity.
Reflection and Heart Examination
We urge those considering Rome not to ask, “Does this feel sacred?” but rather:
- “Is this teaching biblically true?”
- “Does this align with the gospel?”
- “Is my heart being drawn by the Spirit—or by the flesh?”
Is your attraction to Rome due to a hunger for reverence, or a hunger for truth? Don’t settle for aesthetic religion. Seek regeneration, not ritual. Seek Christ, not ceremony.
Conclusion
The draw of Roman Catholicism for some Protestants is understandable in an age of shallow evangelicalism. But the solution is not to return to Rome—it is to return to the Scriptures and to Christ alone.
Do not mistake religious ambiance for saving grace. If you are tempted by the aesthetic and tradition of Catholicism, ask whether what you’re truly longing for is a born-again experience with the living God.
Turn to Scripture. Seek sound doctrine. Treasure Christ. And reject all counterfeit gospels, no matter how beautiful they may seem.
Study the error of the Galatians and consider whether Roman Catholicism is a similar error….the implementation of a system which emulates the Mosaic Covenant and its typology as a substitute or shadow rather than the reality.
Read Louis Berkhof’s book titled Manual of Christian Doctrine, which is replete with Scriptural references and was written for serious young men who wanted to understand the teachings of the Bible in the early twentieth century.
Some may interpret this criticism as an attack upon Roman Catholics themselves. I would rather have an observant conservative Roman Catholic as a neighbor than an avowed unbeliever.
An evangelical Christian has more in common with a conservative Roman Catholic than a “Progressive” Christian who has sold himself to the world and its false ideologies.
The labors of conservative Roman Catholics for the cause of abortion and cultural decline are admirable, particularly young men like TFP Student Action and commentators such as Michael Knowles and Matt Walsh. We should not consider conservative Roman Catholics to be enemies in these regards.
I am concerned with the state of their salvation and spiritual well-being due to Roman Catholic beliefs that contradict Scripture and the Gospel, though. And, I am concerned for the salvation of young men who are pursuing their example.
I understand that some Roman Catholics ridicule regeneration and the need to be born again.
I have one thing to say in response to them. You must be born again (John 3:6-7). Those in Adam cannot worship God in spirit and truth. You need to be reborn in Christ. There are other posts on my blog that cover this.
Regards,
Robert Sparkman
rob@christiannewsjunkie.com
RELATED CONTENT
Pastors associated with the Southern Baptist Convention offer comments upon the popularity of Roman Catholicism amongst seeking young men and their views underlying it.
Concerning the Related Content section, I encourage everyone to evaluate the content carefully.
Some sources of information may reflect a libertarian and/or atheistic perspective. I may not agree with all of their opinions, but they offer some worthwhile comments on the topic under discussion.
Additionally, language used in the videos may be coarse. Coarse language does not reflect my personal standards.
Also, I do not acknowledge that anyone transitions from male to female, and vice versa. While I might use the language of the left for purposes of communication, like the words transgender or cisgender, I do not believe their concepts. Trans men are women deluded into thinking they are men, and trans women are men deluded into thinking they are women. Trans men are not men, and trans women are not women.
Finally, those on the left often criticize my sources of information, which are primarily conservative and/or Christian. Truth is truth, regardless of how we feel about it. Leftists are largely led by their emotion rather than facts. It is no small wonder that they would criticize the sources that I provide. And, ultimately, my wordview is governed by Scripture. Many of my critics are not biblical Christians.
Feel free to offer your comments below. Respectful comments without expletives and personal attacks will be posted and I will respond to them.
Comments are closed after sixty days due to spamming issues from internet bots. You can always send me an email at rob@christiannewsjunkie.com if you want to comment on something, though.
I will continue to add items to the Related Content section as opportunities present themselves.