In American evangelicalism today, there is a heated discussion over how salvation actually works. One group, often referred to as Provisionists, emphasizes God’s love for all people and each person’s ability to respond freely to the Gospel. The other group, Calvinists, highlights God’s sovereignty in salvation, His eternal election, and the human inability to choose Christ apart from divine grace.
This essay compares the two views. We’ll look at their beliefs, their leaders, the history behind them, and the Scriptures they use. We will also evaluate common misunderstandings (called strawmen), personality tendencies, emotional appeals, and the influence of modern political values like “equality” on theology.
I will use the description “Reformed Baptist/Particular Baptist” as the description for the Calvinistic view, as my personal affiliation as a “Calvinist” is associated with them rather than the paedobaptist crowd.
Overview of the Two Systems
Provisionism
Provisionism teaches that God has made salvation possible for every person. While humanity is fallen, people still retain the ability to respond to the Gospel if given a clear opportunity. Salvation depends on a person’s free choice to trust in Christ.
Key Teaching: God “provides” salvation to all and does not prevent anyone from accepting the offer.
Reformed Baptist / Particular Baptist Theology
This view is grounded in the Reformation and the doctrines of grace (TULIP). It teaches that mankind is totally depraved and cannot choose God without first being regenerated by the Holy Spirit. Salvation is entirely a work of God from beginning to end.
Key Teaching: God sovereignly chooses to save some out of the mass of fallen humanity, and Christ died to fully save those people, not merely make salvation possible.
Key Principles of Each View
Provisionism
- Universal atonement (Christ died for all).
- Libertarian free will.
- Prevenient grace (grace that restores moral ability to believe).
- Faith is not a divine gift, but a free human response.
- Election is corporate, not individual.
- God’s justice requires equal opportunity for all.
Reformed Baptist Theology
- Total depravity and inability.
- Unconditional election.
- Particular redemption (definite atonement).
- Irresistible grace.
- Regeneration precedes faith.
- Perseverance of the saints.
Key Figures and Organizations
Provisionist Leaders and Ministries
- Leighton Flowers – Former Calvinist, now leading Provisionist voice through Soteriology 101.
- David Allen – Advocate for unlimited atonement.
- Herschel Hobbs – Helped write the 1963 Baptist Faith & Message.
- Connect 316 – Organization promoting the “Traditional Statement” (2012).
Reformed Baptist Leaders and Ministries
- John Owen – Theologian who strongly defended definite atonement.
- Charles Spurgeon – Famous preacher who called himself a Calvinist Baptist.
- James White – Apologist, critic of Provisionism and Arminianism.
- Founders Ministries – Promotes Reformed Baptist theology within the Southern Baptist Convention (SBC).
- 1689 LBCF Fellowship – Churches adhering to the 1689 London Baptist Confession.
Glossary of Terms
| Term | Definition |
|---|---|
| Total Depravity | All people are affected by sin and unable to come to God without grace. |
| Prevenient Grace | Grace that enables belief without guaranteeing it (Provisionist view). |
| Regeneration | Being born again—made alive spiritually by God. |
| Libertarian Free Will | The idea that humans have total freedom to choose or reject God. |
| Compatibilism | Humans act freely, within the constraints of their nature, but always according to God’s sovereign will (Reformed view). |
| Corporate Election | God chose a group (the Church), not specific individuals. |
| Definite Atonement | Christ’s death secured salvation for the elect. |
| Effectual Calling | The Holy Spirit’s irresistible drawing of the elect to faith. |
Historical Timeline
Provisionism
- 1610 – Remonstrants present Arminian theology in response to Calvinism.
- 1800s – Arminian influence spreads among Baptists.
- 1963 – Herschel Hobbs helps draft SBC’s Baptist Faith & Message.
- 2012 – Traditional Statement codifies modern Provisionism in the SBC.
Reformed Baptists
- 1644 – First London Baptist Confession issued by Particular Baptists.
- 1689 – Second London Baptist Confession (modeled on Westminster Confession).
- 1700s – Spread through English Baptists and into America.
- 1800s – Flourishes under Spurgeon.
- 1900s–Today – Recovered by Reformed Baptist movements and seminaries.
Scriptures and Doctrinal Proofs
Reformed Baptist Key Passages:
- Romans 9:15–16 – “I will have mercy on whom I have mercy…”
- John 6:44 – “No one can come to me unless the Father… draws him.”
- Ephesians 2:1–5 – “Dead in trespasses… made alive together with Christ.”
- Acts 13:48 – “As many as were appointed to eternal life believed.”
Provisionist Key Passages:
- John 3:16 – “God so loved the world…”
- 1 Timothy 2:4 – “Desires all people to be saved…”
- 2 Peter 3:9 – “Not wishing that any should perish…”
Reformed Baptist Counter-Criticisms
Reformed Baptists argue that:
- Human inability is total (Rom. 3:11, 1 Cor. 2:14), not partial.
- Universal atonement undermines the power and purpose of Christ’s death (John 10:11).
- God’s love is expressed differently: general to all (Matt. 5:45), covenantal to the elect (Eph. 5:25).
- Faith is a gift (Phil. 1:29, Eph. 2:8), not a human-generated act.
- Election is personal and before time (Eph. 1:4–5), not corporate or reactive.
Strawman Arguments from Both Sides
Provisionist Strawmen Against Reformed Baptists:
- “Calvinists believe God forces people to be saved or damned.”
- “If Calvinism is true, evangelism is pointless.”
- “Reformed theology makes God the author of sin.”
- “You can’t love a God who doesn’t love everyone the same way.”
Reformed Baptist Strawmen Against Provisionists:
- “Provisionists believe they save themselves.”
- “They think man is good and doesn’t need grace.”
- “They’re just semi-Pelagians in disguise.”
- “Provisionism is just emotional Arminianism with a new label.”
Reality: Most Provisionists deny Pelagianism and affirm the need for grace, though they redefine how grace works. Many Reformed Baptists do evangelize fervently and deeply love the lost—but they also affirm God’s ultimate control over salvation.
Are Provisionists Guided by Emotion?
Provisionists are often driven by emotional appeals to fairness, justice, and God’s love. Their system tends to:
- Soften the doctrine of sin.
- Flatten God’s differentiated love.
- Emphasize “choice” over divine sovereignty.
Many sermons and podcasts focus on how Calvinism makes God look “unfair.” While emotion is not inherently wrong, theology must not be built on how we feel about God’s actions—it must be built on what Scripture reveals.
Influence of American Political Ideals on Provisionism
Is Provisionism Theologically Americanized?
Yes, in many ways. Provisionism often mirrors American political ideals such as:
- Equality of Opportunity – If salvation isn’t offered equally to all, it’s unjust.
- Democratic Consent – People should “vote” to receive salvation.
- Autonomy – Personal freedom must be preserved at all costs.
These ideas make sense in the American political system but fall short in theology.
God’s Economy vs. Earthly Justice
| Feature | God’s Sovereign Economy | American Political Justice |
|---|---|---|
| Authority Source | God’s eternal will (Rom. 9) | Consent of the governed |
| Human Role | Totally dependent on grace | Autonomous and rights-bearing |
| Election | Unconditional (Eph. 1:4–5) | Democratic, individualistic |
| Justice | Rooted in God’s character and decree | Rooted in equality and fairness |
| Love | Varied: general and covenantal | Equalized: everyone deserves the same |
| Salvation | By sovereign mercy (Titus 3:5) | By human decision and cooperation |
God does not operate by political fairness. He does not owe salvation to anyone. Salvation is a gift, not a right. While earthly governments should treat people with equal dignity, God is not bound by human expectations of egalitarianism.
Conclusion: Salvation Belongs to God, Not to Us
At the heart of the debate between Provisionism and Reformed Baptists is this question: Who is truly sovereign—man or God? Provisionism, though earnest, often tries to protect God’s character by reshaping Him to fit human expectations of love and justice. Reformed Baptists, on the other hand, trust Scripture’s portrayal of God, even when His ways are mysterious or offensive to modern values.
If salvation is of the Lord (Jonah 2:9), then we must let God define the terms—and rejoice that He saves any of us at all.
S.D.G.,
Robert Sparkman
christiannewsjunkie@gmail.com
P.S. This topic is not my primary focus in terms of study. I prefer to address current events, wokeness and its threat to society and the Church, along with more basic topics in Christianity. If I have misrepresented either position, please let me know in the comments below. Forewarning: if your comment is not well ordered and reflects Calvinist Derangement Syndrome, I may decide not to respond. RLS.
RELATED CONTENT
Concerning the Related Content section, I encourage everyone to evaluate the content carefully.
I think the content is worthwhile, but it may contain opinions or language I don’t agree with.
Realize that I sometimes use phrases like “trans man”, “trans woman”, “transgender” or similar language for ease of communication. Obviously, as a conservative Christian, I don’t believe anyone has ever become the opposite sex.
Feel free to offer your comments below. Respectful comments without expletives and personal attacks will be posted and I will respond to them.
Comments are closed after sixty days due to spamming issues from internet bots. You can always send me an email at christiannewsjunkie@gmail.com if you want to comment on something afterwards, though.
I will continue to add videos and other items to the Related Content section as opportunities present themselves.